Sign In

Delhi News Daily

  • Home
  • Fashion
  • Business
  • World News
  • Technology
  • Sports
  • Politics
  • Lifestyle
  • Entertainment
Reading: Jane Street saga: Nilesh Shah gives 3 reasons why no HFT will do it in China – Delhi News Daily
Share

Delhi News Daily

Font ResizerAa
Search
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
© 2022 Foxiz News Network. Ruby Design Company. All Rights Reserved.
Delhi News Daily > Blog > Business > Jane Street saga: Nilesh Shah gives 3 reasons why no HFT will do it in China – Delhi News Daily
Business

Jane Street saga: Nilesh Shah gives 3 reasons why no HFT will do it in China – Delhi News Daily

delhinewsdaily
Last updated: July 8, 2025 1:27 pm
delhinewsdaily
Share
SHARE


Contents
Regulatory muscle must match market complexityLive Events5 reforms to prevent another Jane Street:1. Strengthen regulatory powers2. Create counterbalancing mechanisms3. Treat commercial crime seriously4. Curb speculative mania5. Prioritise financial educationBeyond detection: a warning for the future
India’s capital markets may be vulnerable to sophisticated derivatives manipulation because, unlike China, they lack key deterrents that would dissuade high-frequency traders (HFTs) from attempting similar schemes, according to Nilesh Shah, managing director of Kotak Mahindra Mutual Fund.

In a sharply-worded opinion piece published in the Financial Express, Shah drew a stark contrast between Indian and Chinese markets, highlighting three structural deterrents that he believes make such manipulative conduct nearly impossible in China.

“First, Chinese markets are largely closed to foreign speculators for such activities, limiting access,” Shah wrote. “Second, Chinese regulators wield formidable power, employing tactics akin to sam, dam, dand, bhed (persuasion, fines, punishment, or division) to enforce deterrence and compliance. Third, the memory of a well-known hedge fund being squeezed by the China Investment Corporation in a short renminbi trade serves as a powerful deterrent.”

Regulatory muscle must match market complexity

Shah argued that while the Securities and Exchange Board of India’s (Sebi) recent action against Jane Street showcases its surveillance and forensic capabilities, more needs to be done to make India’s market enforcement truly effective.

He pointed to the persistence of unresolved cases from the 1992 securities scam and drew comparisons with the U.S. legal system, where mechanisms exist to recover investor losses, citing the Bernie Madoff case.

ET logo

Live Events


Shah likened the Indian F&O markets to a village derivatives bazaar where a powerful trader repeatedly exploits a rigged cycle, drawing a parallel to Jane Street’s alleged behaviour. He cautioned that India’s institutional investors, constrained by regulation and trading strategies such as volume-weighted average price (VWAP), lack the aggression and agility to act as a counterforce to such entities.“A new institutional mechanism equipped with advanced data analytics, high-speed connectivity, and access to leverage is needed,” Shah said, “as is the ability to act decisively to neutralise HFT dominance.”Sebi on July 3 barred U.S.-based Jane Street and four affiliated entities from accessing Indian markets, accusing them of manipulating index levels on 18 expiry days over a two-year period and profiting disproportionately from index options trades. The regulator has ordered the impounding of Rs 4,840 crore in alleged illegal gains.

Also read | Rs 735 crore in 1 day! Jane Street’s most profitable day on Dalal Street was built on Nifty Bank’s fall

5 reforms to prevent another Jane Street:

Shah proposed five systemic reforms that he believes are essential to restore integrity, protect retail investors, and ensure India doesn’t become “a playground for manipulative merchants.”

1. Strengthen regulatory powers

Shah called for fortifying Sebi’s enforcement ability with a sharper legal toolkit. While praising the regulator’s data-driven action against Jane Street, he pointed out that India’s justice system lacks the speed and power required to address modern financial frauds.

“Commercial crimes, like market manipulation, often cause greater societal harm but face lenient treatment due to the absence of a ‘dead body’,” Shah said. “Empowering Sebi with robust legal tools and fostering a fear of swift punishment are critical to deterring future violations.”

2. Create counterbalancing mechanisms

Shah warned that India’s institutional investors, constrained by rules and low-risk strategies like volume-weighted average price (VWAP), cannot counterbalance aggressive HFTs like Jane Street.

“A new institutional mechanism equipped with advanced data analytics, high-speed connectivity, and access to leverage is needed,” he said, “as is the ability to act decisively to neutralise HFT dominance.”

3. Treat commercial crime seriously

Drawing parallels with past regulatory failures, Shah said Sebi must go beyond monetary recovery and impose deterrent penalties. He cited the Bhopal gas tragedy as a cautionary tale of limited consequences for catastrophic wrongdoing.

“Sebi’s order against Jane Street… must go beyond recovering manipulated profits,” Shah wrote. “An exemplary penalty is needed to deter future manipulations.”

4. Curb speculative mania

Addressing the surge in retail F&O trading, Shah likened the speculative frenzy to addiction fuelled by greed and social media hype.

“In our F&O markets, a massacre occurs every week, where millions of Indians get killed economically, not by bullets but by their greed,” he said. He compared quick-profit seekers to drug addicts and the mythological demon Raktabij: “Slay one, and a hundred more emerge.”

Shah advocated statutory warnings on derivatives trading, tighter restrictions on promotion, and possibly a levy on F&O trades to fund investor education and protection.

5. Prioritise financial education

Calling education the ultimate antidote to retail vulnerability, Shah urged regulators to scale up literacy efforts and implement tougher gatekeeping for risky products.

“The anti-dote to greed is financial education,” he said, recommending that traders be required to pass qualifying exams before being allowed to engage in leveraged trades.

Beyond detection: a warning for the future

While Sebi’s action has stirred much-needed conversation, Shah’s central message is that enforcement alone is not enough.

“Unchecked financial muscle and speculative frenzy can destabilise markets leaving retail investors vulnerable,” Shah said. “Only by addressing these issues head-on can India prevent its markets from becoming playgrounds for manipulative merchants.”

Also read | Jane Street clampdown raises big questions for Sebi: Can the regulator stop another derivatives fraud?

(Disclaimer: Recommendations, suggestions, views and opinions given by the experts are their own. These do not represent the views of the Economic Times)



Source link

Share This Article
Twitter Email Copy Link Print
What do you think?
Love0
Sad0
Happy0
Sleepy0
Angry0
Dead0
Wink0
Previous Article News18 Nitish Kumar ‘On The Job’: 35% Quota For Bihar Women In Govt Posts, Youth Commission To Be Set Up – Delhi News Daily
Next Article From Edgbaston to Lord’s | Chasing the 3rd Test | Travel Vlog – Delhi News Daily
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts

  • Ben Stokes: On plan for Shubman Gill, toss decision, pitch, Jofra Archer – Delhi News Daily
  • Motilal Oswal see 4% downside for Bharat Dynamics, starts coverage with neutral call amid lofty valuations – Delhi News Daily
  • Tharoor Shares Survey Projecting Him As Kerala CM Choice, Congress Leader Calls It ‘Cooked Up’ – Delhi News Daily
  • ‘Such good English’: Trump’s compliment to Liberian President triggers criticism – watch – Times of India – Delhi News Daily
  • Apple Might Be Developing a ChatGPT-Style Chatbot for Its Support App – Delhi News Daily

Recent Comments

No comments to show.

You Might Also Like

Business

Angel One shares drop 7% after June and Q1 FY26 business update – Delhi News Daily

Angel One shares fell 7% to Rs 2,740 on the BSE in Friday’s trade following the release of its June…

3 Min Read
Business

Trump says Iran has ‘maximum’ two weeks to avoid US air strikes, dismisses Europe peace efforts – Delhi News Daily

US President Donald Trump said Friday that Iran had a "maximum" of two weeks to avoid possible American air strikes,…

6 Min Read
Business

Clean exits, real reporting: What family offices now want from real estate, highlights Ramashrya Yadav of Integrow AMC – Delhi News Daily

The real estate playbook is rapidly evolving for India’s family offices. Gone are the days of buying a property and…

4 Min Read
Business

Kalpataru raises Rs 708 crore from 9 anchor investors; Singapore’s GIC, Bain Capital lead – Delhi News Daily

Realty developer Kalpataru has raised over Rs 708 crore from nine anchor investors including GIC Singapore, Bain Capital’s GSS Opportunities…

2 Min Read

Delhi News Daily

© Delhi News Daily Network.

Incognito Web Technologies

Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?